Imported Goods That Infringe On Copyrights
By Los Angeles Trademark Infringement Attorney Robert G. Klein, Esq.
I recently received a call from a client who complained that the MP3 players they imported from China were seized and confiscated by the Custom Service at the United States border. The reason for the seizure and forfeiture, I was told, was that the MP3 players had software downloaded in the devices and the software amounted to a copyright infringement. The software was not counterfeit, it merely exceeded the copyright license in that the license precluded the sale by this distributor of that software in the United States. The client wanted to know if they would suffer the same hardship if they imported additional MP3 players without that illicit software.
The answer to that question depended on whether the imported goods infringed on any other party’s intellectual property rights. One concern was whether the soon to be imported MP3 players infringed upon a valid design patent of another manufacturer.
The United States Constitution grants Congress the power to promote the progress of science and useful arts by giving inventors exclusive rights to their inventions for a limited time. Under federal patent law, whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent, with certain specified exceptions. A patent grants the patentee and his or her heirs and assigns the right to exclude others from making, selling, or using the patented article throughout the United States for a term of 17 years. In order to determine if the MP3 players infringed on a valid design patent we conducted a search in the Patent and Trademark office.
When importing goods into the United States one must be mindful of infringing on another’s trademark rights as well as the copyright or patents. Even goods bearing a valid United States trademark that is imported without the consent of the United States trademark holder is an act of trademark infringement. These type of goods are known as “gray-market goods” and can also be seized by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Call For A Case Evaluation